My Forbes.com Articles

Do You Live in a Community Property State or an Equitable Distribution State?

posted by admin 10:31 AM
Thursday, June 16, 2011

Divorce laws differ from state to state, and so the simple truth is this:

Where you live impacts how assets and debts will be divided in your divorce case.

So, in addition to recognizing the difference between separate and marital property, you also must understand the laws that govern your place of residence.

The first step is to determine whether you live in a Community Property State or an Equitable Distribution State.

There are nine Community Property States: Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin. Couples living in Alaska can “opt in” for community property, and Puerto Rico is a community property jurisdiction.

(You may be interested to know that the Community Property system is derived from Spanish law, and that’s why it’s found predominantly in the southwestern states.)

The remaining 41 states are known as Equitable Distribution States (or Common Law States).

What’s the difference between a Community Property State and an Equitable Distribution State?

In a Community Property State, both spouses are typically considered equal owners of all marital property. In other words, if you live in a Community Property State, whatever you earn or acquire during the marriage is co-owned by both parties, regardless of who earned it or whose name is on the title. That means whatever you earn or acquire during the marriage is spilt 50-50 during a divorce.

If you live in an Equitable Distribution State, the law “sees” assets somewhat differently.  In an Equitable Distribution State, if your name appears on an asset (the deed to a house or the title to a car, e.g.), you are considered the owner. However, in an Equitable Distribution State, your spouse has the legal right to claim a fair and equitable portion of those assets in a divorce.

The equitable distribution of assets may result in a 50-50 split of marital property, or it may not. The goal in an Equitable Distribution State is not a 50-50 split. The goal is a fair (equitable) distribution of family property.

A variety of different factors are considered when dividing family property in an Equitable Distribution State. For example, equitable distribution may be based on:

  • the length of the  marriage
  • the age and health of the parties
  • the income and future earning capacity of parties
  • the standard of living established during the marriage
  • the value of homemaking and childcare provided during the marriage
  • the value of the investment one party made to help with the education, training of the other party
  • other factors

Please keep in mind that the entire discussion above involve marital property. Separate property is a different matter.

Whether you live in a Community Property State or an Equitable Distribution state,  assets that you bring into the marriage or receive individually (an inheritance or your grandmother’s diamond ring, e.g.) remain yours. This separate property is exactly that –separate –unless you co-mingle it with marital property. For instance, if you deposited the inheritance from your parents into a joint bank account, it’s likely that those funds would no longer be considered separate property. Instead, once co-mingled, these funds would be considered marital property and subject to division as required  by your state’s laws.

In a nutshell, here’s the difference between a Community Property State and an Equitable Distribution State:

In a Community Property State, marital property is divided 50-50.

In an Equitable Distribution State, marital property is divided equitably, based on a variety of factors.

Assets aren’t necessarily the only thing acquired during marriage. Debt is often acquired, too. And just as assets are divided in divorce, debt is divided, as well. Generally speaking, the division of debt follows the same principles as the division of assets. For example, in most Community Property States, both spouses are equally responsible for the repayment of debt acquired during the marriage, even if only one spouse enjoyed the benefit. (I’ll discuss the division of debt in more detail in a future blog post.)

Okay. Are you now feeling comfortable with the distinction between Community Property and Equitable Distribution States? You are? Great! Then, I won’t feel too badly about offering this one last wrinkle:

A few states have laws with both Community Property and Equitable Distribution characteristics.

(As I’ve said before, the division of assets can get complicated quickly!)

Please, consult with your divorce attorney to learn which laws are specific to your state, and remember, when it comes to divorce, geography is critically important. Regardless of where you live, it’s essential that you seek guidance from a qualified divorce team concerning the particular circumstances of your individual case.

All articles/blog posts are for informational purposes only, and  do not constitute legal advice. If you require legal advice, retain a  lawyer licensed in your jurisdiction. The opinions expressed are solely  those of the author, who is not an attorney.

 

Share this:
Share this page via Email Share this page via Stumble Upon Share this page via Digg this Share this page via Facebook Share this page via Twitter  Pin It
Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks


11 Responses to “Do You Live in a Community Property State or an Equitable Distribution State?”

  1. [...] (For a more detailed discussion on how assets are divided, see my earlier post about the differences between Community Property States and Equitable Distribution States.) [...]

  2. [...] (For a more detailed discussion on how assets are divided, see my earlier post about the differences between Community Property States and Equitable Distribution States.) [...]

  3. [...] Lessons Women Can Learn from the Demi and Ashton Break-up Rumors – How To Get A Divorce on Do You Live in a Community Property State or an Equitable Distribution State?Five Financial Lessons Women Can Learn from the Demi and Ashton Break-up Rumors – Forbes on Do You [...]

  4. [...] own set of laws governing the division of a family business in divorce. For starters, there are nine Community Property States – Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington and Wisconsin [...]

  5. [...] (For a more detailed discussion on how assets are divided, see my earlier post about the differences between Community Property States and Equitable Distribution States.) [...]

  6. [...] year marriage will now be considered marital property –and because California is a Community Property state it will be split 50-50. (And in case you’re wondering, she’s reportedly worth $75 million, [...]

  7. [...] capacity may all be considered. (See a more detailed discussion in my earlier blog post about the difference between Community Property and Equitable Distribution States.) “Half of everything” is a common refrain, but if you’re a 60 year-old homemaker with no [...]

  8. [...] capacity may all be considered. (See a more detailed discussion in my earlier blog post about the difference between Community Property and Equitable Distribution States.) “Half of everything” is a common refrain, but if you’re a 60 year-old homemaker with no [...]

  9. [...] of its value at that time. However, as part of your divorce settlement process –and dependent on the division of property regulations in your state –you might want to show that the property has gained value over your marriage, perhaps due to [...]

  10. [...] of its value at that time. However, as part of your divorce settlement process –and dependent on the division of property regulations in your state –you might want to show that the property has gained value over your marriage, perhaps due to [...]

  11. [...] capacity may all be considered. (See a more detailed discussion in my earlier blog post about the difference between Community Property and Equitable Distribution States.) “Half of everything” is a common refrain, but if you’re a 60 year-old homemaker with no [...]